DJ Lagway’s upcoming first start at Florida is highly anticipated, as he brings the promise of a five-star recruit to a program eager to return to national prominence. His debut will undoubtedly draw comparisons to other recent five-star quarterbacks who faced the pressure of early playing time at major programs.
Looking at recent history, these highly-touted freshmen have had varying levels of success. Trevor Lawrence, who took over as Clemson’s starting quarterback in 2018, is one of the most successful examples. After seizing the starting role early in the season, Lawrence led Clemson to an undefeated season and a national championship, showcasing the immediate impact a five-star freshman can have.
On the other hand, players like Bo Nix at Auburn in 2019 had a more inconsistent freshman year. While Nix showed flashes of brilliance, including leading a game-winning drive against Oregon in his debut, his overall performance was marked by ups and downs, typical of a freshman adjusting to the college game. Similarly, Spencer Rattler, another highly ranked recruit, had a mixed freshman season at Oklahoma in 2020. Rattler displayed impressive arm talent but also struggled with decision-making and consistency, leading to some early benchings before settling in.
Then there’s Bryce Young, who followed in the footsteps of other Alabama greats in 2020. Despite not starting until his sophomore year, Young’s freshman year laid a foundation for his eventual Heisman Trophy win in 2021.
Lagway’s situation mirrors that of these predecessors. He has the raw talent and physical tools to succeed, but his adjustment to the speed and complexity of college defenses will be key. If he can follow in the footsteps of someone like Lawrence or even Young, Florida fans have reason for optimism. However, if his experience mirrors those of Nix or Rattler, there may be growing pains before he hits his stride.
